Home / Guides / Are Extended Warranties Worth It? An Honest Breakdown
Buying guide
Are Extended Warranties Worth It? An Honest Breakdown
Extended warranties are pushed hard at checkout because they're highly profitable for the seller. That doesn't make them always wrong — but it means you should decide deliberately, not under pressure.
Why stores push them so hard
Extended warranties and protection plans carry very high margins for retailers — often a large share of the price is profit. On average, buyers pay more in premiums than they get back in claims (that's how the product is designed to work). So the default math favors skipping them — with specific exceptions.
When an extended warranty can make sense
- Expensive repairs, fragile tech: items where a single repair would be painful and failures aren't rare.
- Coverage the manufacturer warranty lacks: accidental damage on a laptop or phone, for instance, which standard warranties exclude.
- You'd genuinely struggle to absorb a surprise repair — the plan buys budgeting certainty.
When to skip it
- Reliable, cheap-to-replace items — the expected payout doesn't justify the cost.
- Coverage you already have — many credit cards extend the manufacturer warranty for free; check before paying.
- Overlap with the manufacturer warranty — some plans mostly duplicate the first year you already get free.
A smarter middle path
Instead of buying every plan offered, consider self-insuring: skip the plans and set aside what you'd have spent. For most people, across many purchases, that fund comes out ahead — and you keep the money when nothing breaks. Reserve extended warranties for the few high-cost, failure-prone, hard-to-absorb items where they truly earn their keep.